⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
I adore this podcast. A compelling story, a relatable main character, great voice acting, and hour long episodes. Loads of queer rep that isn’t built around the story. It’s just a part of the world. I wish there was more like this one.
— sps.with.a.smile, July 2023, Podchaser
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
PERFECT PODCAST
This audio-drama had me enthralled the whole way through!

Excellent dialogue, awesome sound design, and fantastic mystery writing are highlights of this show, along with important and introspective themes of otherness and power.

Definitely a must watch for anyone looking for some casual representation, thrilling twists, heart-wrenching feelings, and just overall good vibes.
— Lolatheartist, Dec 2022, Apple Podcasts
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
So happy to have found this podcast/ full cast AD. It took a full episode plus to totally get my buy in but I am totally hooked now. Audio quality is well above above average, the acting is believable for the genre. The world in this docudrama is reminiscent of a dark comic book with fantasy vibes. It doesn’t overwhelm with too much info too soon, just enough so you don’t feel lost. The mystery/intrigue is subtle. It has all of my favorite characteristics. It is definitely worth a listen!
— Zurayah, Nov 2022, Podchaser
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
OBSESSED
Constantly excited for new episodes. Love the queer inclusivity that is incorporated in a casual way that fits effortlessly. Writers and voice actors are obviously talented and put in lots of hard work. Can’t wait for many more eps to come! 💚
— Jerry Nago, May 2022, Apple Podcasts

Reviews

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
REALLY EXCELLENT
Deep and intriguing, open to interpretation on many levels. Great cast, clear sound, well produced. Congratulations.
— Nic Voss-Bark, July 2022, Apple Podcasts
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
binged all the episodes that are currently out and I LOVE IT
amazing characters, interesting plot, great voice acting and so much queer rep (which I, as a fellow queer person, require lmao)
not very constructive review but hey you can trust me and give it a listen - it won’t dissapoint!
— edensbackyard, June 2022, Podchaser
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
!!!
I think this is the perfect podcast?? I’m going crazy. Can’t wait to see where this goes!!!
— averagerage, July 2022, Apple Podcasts
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
THE WRITING IS GREAT!
The writing is great; it gives me Night Vale/Alice Isn’t Dead vibes – I like how it’s a podcast within a podcast. It lends a type of tangible realness to the series that makes it feel like it could all be real… And who’s to say it isn’t!
— QuentinWilde, June 2022, Apple Podcasts
I just. I cannot stop thinking about @nightshiftcast: the MUSIC, the worldbuilding, the performances, the LAYERS, the nuance, the twists, the sheer queer urban fantasy pulp fiction of it all! This is what we DESERVE and I need everyone up to date like, yesterday. Best romance involving queer men since The Penumbra Podcast? I think so. Y’ALL ITS REAL GOOD. ITS REAL GOOD
— Ella Watts, Director of Doctor Who: Redacted, via Twitter
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
A full-cast urban fantasy story told through the format of a fictional investigative podcast of a man exploring conspiracies in his city, including a missing person’s case and the secrets behind a megacorp’s super soldier program, in an alternate universe where magic used to be commonplace but suddenly vanished. The story tackles ideas of wanting to improve the world despite feeling helpless, in-universe prejudice (somewhat akin to that against Marvel mutants), and self-discovery. The main character is a determined investigator and is given the runaround on several occassions, but through persistence manages to make connections including supersoldiers and the head of the bio-engineering at the megacorp. As the story progresses mysteries unfold and the main character becomes more able to use his investigations to help others. There are points where I run into one of my biggest problems with the mockumentary conceit and find myself asking ‘why would someone ever publicly share something so personal and incriminating including proof of multiple crimes?’, but it’s mostly not too distracting, is sometimes addressed in the plot, and the reveals of information work otherwise.
— ererva, August 2022, Podchaser
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Truly the best way to describe this is “d*mmit, Seb”. This podcast causes me so much stress, which I suppose is the best testament to it’s writing, worldbuilding and overall vibe. I care about the characters so much that I have shouted no into the ether outside in public.
— ItMe, Dec 2022, Podchaser
It’s an incredible epic slow burn world build - think Penumbra Podcast or Silt Verses. It’s also a heart clenching slow burn enemies to lovers romance that will break your heart so hard
— auralqueer, via Tumblr
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Phenomenal audio work! A treat for your ears :) the world of the podcast is one almost like our own, but just a step or two to the left, making for highly entertaining listening as we (and Seb) learn the secrets of Echor City. I’m very excited to see where season two takes us!
— cherrymercury, Jan 2023, Podchaser
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Really great world building so far for a unique modern fantasy. It’s kind of a mix of magic and superheroes. Cool mysteries and great representation with a full cast and pretty good production quality!
— nateglasse, May 2022, Podchaser